• Kelly Twin Paradox

    Yesterday astronaut Scott Kelly returned from nearly a year in free fall aboard the International Space Station to join his identical twin brother Mark back on Earth. Due to their different spacetime paths, I estimate that Scott aged about 9 ms less than his brother, and therefore travelled about 9 ms into the future, becoming one of Earth’s most accomplished time travelers.

    As predicted by the theory of relativity, identical twins Mark and Scott Kelly aged differently during Scott's year in space. Photo credit: Robert Markowitz / NASA.
    As predicted by the theory of relativity, identical twins Mark and Scott Kelly aged differently during Scott’s year in space. Photo credit: Robert Markowitz / NASA.

    The familiar Pythagorean line element dl2 = dx2 + dy2 + dz2 (and corresponding metric) describes the geometry of Euclidean space. The Lorentzian line element – 2 = ds2 = – dt2 + dx2 + dy2 + dz2 = – dt2 + dl2 (and corresponding semimetric) describes the flat spacetime of special relativity, where space is measured in light-years and time in years. The Einsteinian line element 2 = gμνdxμdxν describes the curved spacetime of general relativity, with an implied sum over the indices. From third semester physics, in flat spacetime the proper time increment = √(dt2dl2) = dt√(1 – v2) = dt/γ, where the relativistic stretch γ ≥ 1 regulates the time dilation. More generally, the length Δτ = ∫ dτ of a spacetime worldline is the proper time or aging along it (which is most evident in the observer’s rest frame).

    In the curved, approximately Kerr spacetime of the rotating Earth, clocks tick faster with increasing altitude but slower with increasing speed. In low Earth orbit aboard the ISS, the speed effect dominates the altitude effect, sending Scott Kelly about 10 ms – 1 ms = 9 ms into the future. Furthermore, in curved spacetime, multiple free fall or geodesic paths between the same two events can have different lengths or aging, which can desynchronize clocks or twins without proper (as opposed to coordinate) acceleration — and without paradox.

  • A New Kind of Astronomy

    One of the first things I did as a grad student in 1982 was tour the Laser Interferometer Gravitational Wave Observatory (LIGO) prototype on the Caltech campus about a block from my dorm. It was housed in a utilitarian L-shaped building wrapped around the corner of another building. I toyed with the idea of working with Kip Thorne and Ron Drever on LIGO, perhaps making a career of it. I would be a small part of a large and long collaboration, but one that would probably make history. I chose a different path, but I never forgot LIGO, and I have closely followed its progress ever since. In 2007, I even co-advised Stephen Poprocki’s senior I.S. “Bayesian Source Direction Determination for Gravitational-Wave Bursts”, which was a small contribution to the LIGO effort.

    A packed crowd of Wooster physicists eagerly awaits the news from LIGO.
    A packed crowd of Wooster physicists eagerly awaits the news from LIGO.

    Last Thursday morning, I was thrilled to sit with the Wooster physics department in a crowded Taylor 111 watching the LIGO team announce the first direct detection of gravitational waves. I got goosebumps reading the discovery paper in Physical Review Letters. However, during a later replay of the press conference, I heard Kip say Ron Drever was too ill to be there, but his family sent their best wishes. Sadly, the New York Times reports that Ron is in a nursing home in Scotland suffering from dementia, this historic discovery apparently too late for him to savor.

    Audible chirps as proper distances between LIGO mirrors change by a few thousandths of a proton diameter in response to a binary black hole merger over a billion years ago.
    Audible chirps as proper distances between LIGO mirrors change by a few thousandths of a proton diameter in response to a binary black hole merger over a billion years ago.

    Gravitational waves are the analogue for gravity of what light is for electromagnetism but about 10^{40} times weaker. Over a billion years ago, two black holes spiraled together, merged, and rung down, radiating away the equivalent of about 3 solar masses of energy in a third of a second with more power than the luminosity of the entire observable universe. Last September 14th, gravity waves from the merger passed through Earth, stretching and expanding the 4-km long arms of the two LIGO interferometers, which were thousands of miles and several milliseconds apart, by a few thousandths of a proton’s width. The resulting chirps in strain were visible to the eye above the noisy backgrounds. History had been made, and a new era in astronomy had begun.

    The moment we first saw the now-famous plots of the gravitational wave signals.
    The moment we first saw the now-famous plots of the gravitational wave signals.

  • Hillary & Armstrong

    You’re probably familiar with the iconic photograph of Edmund Hillary standing atop Earth’s highest mountain wearing an oxygen mask in air so thin the sky is almost black as space — but apparently Hillary declined to be photographed and instead this photograph is by Hillary of his companion Tenzing Norgay during 1953’s first successful ascent of Mount Everest! You’re probably also familiar with the iconic photograph of Neil Armstrong in a pressure suit standing on the surface of Earth’s airless moon — but actually Armstrong carried the still camera for nearly the entire moonwalk, so  this photograph is by Armstrong of his companion Buzz Aldrin during 1969’s historic Apollo 11 moon landing!

    Tenzing Norgay on Everest, 1953 May 29, and Buzz Aldrin on Moon, 1969 July 20. .
    Iconic photos: Tenzing Norgay on Everest, 1953 May 29, and Buzz Aldrin on Moon, 1969 July 20. Photo credits: Edmund Hlllary and Neil Armstrong.

    Hillary and Armstrong became friends later in life and even travelled together. In 1985, the pair flew from arctic Canada to the North Pole leaving the memorable logbook page reproduced below.

    Page from a logbook at an arctic inn.
    Page from a logbook at an arctic inn where Hillary and Armstrong stayed during their July 1985 North Pole trip. Presumably the exclamation points were added later. Credit: Stephen Braham.

  • Ticktock Deadbeat Escapement

    The escapement is one of history’s greatest inventions; it enables a collection of wood or metal to tell time. The animation below illustrates a pendulum clock’s deadbeat escapement, apparently introduced by Richard Townseley, Thomas Tompion, and George Graham in the late 1600s and early 1700s. The escapement wheel transfers energy to the pendulum to overcome frictional damping while periodically stopping (and escaping) to count the number of oscillations.

    Swinging pendulum
    Swinging pendulum (green) periodically locks escape wheel (red) interrupting fall of weight (brown) as escape well periodically nudges pendulum to compensate for frictional damping. (You may need to click to see the animation.)

    The swinging pendulum (green) extends below each frame; a length of one meter provides a swing of about one second (and a period of about two seconds). The pallets attached to the pendulum periodically engage the teeth of the escape wheel (red) in two ways: near the extremes of the pendulum’s swings, the teeth hit the pallets’ curved faces concentric with the pendulum pivot with a torque-less “dead beat” and the wheel locks; near the pendulum’s equilibrium, the teeth hit the pallets’ angled faces clockwise or counter-clockwise to keep the pendulum swinging and the wheel rotates. The energy comes from a falling mass connected to the escape wheel by a rope (brown). This precision ballet provides the ticktock of mechanical clocks and watches.

  • The Falcon Has Landed

    Monday evening, the first of SpaceX’s 70 m (or 230 ft) Falcon 9 full thrust launch vehicles successfully deployed 11 satellites to low Earth orbit — and performed reversal, supersonic retrograde, and landing burns to return the first stage to Cape Canaveral. Recent upgrades to the Falcon 9 include densified oxidizer and fuel, with liquid oxygen supercooled to 66.5 K (or −340 °F) and the kerosene fuel RP-1 cooled to 266 K (or 20 °F) to store more energy per unit volume and help increase performance by about 1/3.

    Falcon 9 first stage lands back at Cape Canaveral.
    The 48-m Falcon 9 first stage lands back at Cape Canaveral after launching the second stage and 11 satellites into Earth orbit, 2015 December 21.

    Thanks SpaceX for this thrilling achievement and historic first, which may eventually radically lower space transportation costs, and thanks for sharing it with us live as it happened! If you missed the SpaceX broadcast, check out the landing excerpt, currently available on You Tube, for a great natural high.

  • ER = EPR?

    This month is the 100th anniversary of Albert Einstein’s November 1915 discovery of the gravitational field equations of General Relativity, in which test masses move along the straightest possible paths (called geodesics) in spacetime curved by the density and flux of energy and momentum (including mass and pressure). General Relativity allows spacetime to be topologically doubly connected. In the “wormhole” depicted below (using two different embeddings), the distance across the flat region may be large even if the distance through the tube is small. Traversable wormholes, like the one in the movie Interstellar, might be propped open by exotic matter of negative energy density and provide shortcuts across the universe. Such structures are sometimes called Einstein-Rosen bridges, after a 1935 paper by Einstein and Nathan Rosen.

    wormhole
    A wormhole is a geometry of four-dimensional spacetime in which two regions of the universe are connected by a “shortcut” consisting of two “mouths” connected by a short narrow “throat”.

    Also this month, several research teams reported the best yet experimental realizations of quantum entanglement, in which pairs of particles interact so that each particle cannot be described independently regardless of their separation. For example, an electron and positron in the ground state of positronium can annihilate into two oppositely traveling photons whose spins are completely correlated, so that measurement of one spin determines the other even if the measurements are spacelike (or so far apart that no signal could connect them). In the visual metaphor below, a Necker cube outline can be interpreted two ways, representing a photon in a superposition of two spins; similarly, a pair of Necker cubes can be interpreted two ways, representing measurements of its correlated parts. Such “spooky action at a distance” is sometimes called an EPR correlation after another 1935 paper by Einstein, Boris Podolski, and Rosen.

    Necker cube analogy for quantum mechanics
    Single ambiguous Necker cube is a metaphor for quantum superposition, while a pair of ambiguous Necker cubes is a metaphor for quantum entanglement.

    Recent discussions of the black hole information paradox and the holographic principle in anti-de-Sitter-space model universes suggest a relationship between wormholes and quantum entanglement that may elucidate the nature of spacetime itself: Can Einstein-Rosen bridges explain Einstein-Podolski-Rosen correlations? Is ER = EPR?

  • The Martian

    Ridley Scott’s The Martian (2015) is the best Mars movie I have yet seen. Genuinely faithful to Andy Weir’s popular novel, The Martian chronicles astronaut Mark Whatney’s struggle to survive on Mars, after being accidentally stranded there, and the efforts by NASA and Whatney’s crew to rescue him. The story emphasizes the problem-solving character and skill of scientists and engineers in the celebrated tradition of the Apollo 13 rescue.

    Astronaut on Mars
    Actor Matt Damon plays astronaut Mark Whatney marooned on a largely realistic Mars.

    I especially like the scenes of Whatney living, farming, walking, and driving on a mostly realistic Mars, with a near-terrestrial day-night cycle, authentic dust and sand and sky, including high wispy clouds and dust devils. I’d prefer less atmospheric pressure and sounds in Mars’ thin air (and space’s vacuum), more radiation protection and dust mitigation, and water from heating regolith (= soil) rather than catalyzing and burning hydrazine (= N2H4). I’d also like more accurate 0.38g surface gravity on Mars and more natural microgravity aboard the Hermes interplanetary spaceship (whose size and complexity I’d decrease while reducing the crew from 6 to 4).

    Indeed, The Martian makes me eager for more, especially for the real thing. I remember pausing one night to stare at the moon when people briefly lived on its surface during the Apollo program, and alongside that thrilling memory is the longing for another: to gaze at the ruddy dot of Mars amidst the stars while knowing other people live there — or to live there myself. As SpaceX founder Elon Musk said, it would be wonderful to be born on Earth and die on Mars*.
    —————–
    * But not in the landing.

  • 19th Century Foreground, 20th Century Background

    Although some early aviation aficionados allege other flights (or hops) preceding the Wright brothers’ experiments at Kitty Hawk on 1903 December 17, the Wright Flyer did fly four times that day, including a final flight nearly one minute long, with the Wrights famously photo documenting their progress. They never flew that first aircraft again. Instead, they went home to Dayton Ohio and built the successively better Flyer II and III and the Model A. Using those aircraft, Wilbur and Orville Wright became the first to fly for one minute, the first to fly for two minutes, for half an hour, for one hour, and for two hours. In fact, all world record flight times between 1903 and 1909 were set by the Wright brothers. They truly were first in flight.

    The Wrights became world famous when they demonstrated their flying machines in Europe in 1908-1909. Wilbur went first and was later joined by brother Orville and sister Katherine. Crowds came to watch them; even King George of England crossed the channel to France to see the modern miracle of flight. In the accompanying photo, farmers with an ox cart pause to watch Wilbur Wright and a passenger fly overhead, the 19th century foreground contrasting with the 20th century background.

    Wright flyer over farmers
    Wilbur Wright instructing a student pilot in Pau, France, passes over an ox cart in 1909.

  • Guest Blog – Nathan Johnson ’16

    Over the past century or so humankind has achieved remarkable feats of science and engineering – at a cost. The impact that our innovations have on the environment has become exceedingly clear. As we progress toward better and faster ways to travel we need to be cognizant of the efficiency and impact of our modes of travel.

    This past summer, I was fortunate enough to be on a team that was working toward new and better aircraft engines. At NASA’s Glenn Research Center, I worked with a research engineer on new materials for General Electric’s GE90-class turbofan aircraft engines. The division I worked for has been developing composite materials to replace metal alloys in the hottest parts of the engine. These composite materials are lighter, stronger, and can burn fuel at higher temperatures and efficiencies, reducing the fuel consumption. All in all, these composites are a huge step forward for engine efficiency.

    But, as with any new and exciting invention, there was a caveat. The new composite materials degrade in the presence of oxygen and water vapor – a huge problem considering that water vapor is a major byproduct of jet fuel consumption. To combat this erosion, I worked on environmental barrier coatings (EBCs). These EBCs are just what their name implies: they act as a barrier between the composite and the aircraft engine environment. Many exciting candidates for EBCs exist, namely rare-earth silicates. For 10 weeks this past summer I tested the fundamental reaction kinetics of some of these materials in the presence of many different substances commonly ingested by aircraft engines, such as sand or ash. EBCs need to be stable at very high temperatures and for long periods of time.

    A Yttrium-based EBC
    This is a sample of a Yttrium-based EBC material after being heated to 1200 deg Celsius for 20 hours. It was heated in the presence of desert sand.

    It was one of the most rewarding and exciting experiences of my life. Not only was I working on a project that is having a huge, immediate impact (these composite materials are being implemented in Boeing aircraft in the coming year) but I also got to work in one of the coolest, most exciting workplaces ever. The engineers and scientists at NASA are the rockstars of aeronautics. My advisor was a young, excited, and brilliant woman who inspired me to work extremely hard and go for my absolute best. NASA opened my eyes to a whole new world of possibilities for my future – including a career at NASA. While getting a position at a NASA center is no easy task, it is something I will certainly be working toward for years to come.

    The summer was a whirlwind of new experiences, new topics, and a whole lot of learning. I walked away with everything I hoped to gain and so much more. The project ended well and persuaded me to consider a wide range of areas for my graduate studies. In the end, the EBCs I worked on ended up not being viable candidates – but hey, that all a part of research.

  • On the Shore of the Arctic Ocean

    It was a privilege to spend the 2014-2015 academic year and summer on sabbatical at the University of Hawai’i in Honolulu. During the last week of July, I stood on the spectacular beach at Kailua near sunset and said to myself “wow, wow, wow”. A week later, on my way home, I stood on the dramatic shore of the Arctic Ocean in Barrow Alaska, the northernmost U.S. settlement in a 45°F rain, a comparably singular experience. The sun set that the day for the first time since May, but due to the cloud cover, I never saw it, as an undirected light illuminated the sky and mud and utilitarian buildings. I returned to the beach the next day, and the heavy winds of the night before had littered the shore with meter-sized icebergs. The native Iñupiat people still practice subsistence whaling, and Barrow is home to some Pacific islanders, including Hawaiians.

    Standing on the shore in the cold rain
    On the shore of the Arctic Ocean, Barrow Alaska, August 2015, 45°F and raining.

Recent Comments

Recent Posts

Categories

Archives

Meta